All reviews and site design © by Thomas M. Wagner. Wink the Astrokitty drawn by Matt Olson. All rights reserved. Book cover artwork is copyrighted by its respective artist and/or publisher.


Search Tips Advanced Search
Search engine by Freefind

Five-Twelfths of Heaven by Melissa Scott3.5 stars

Buy from Barnes & NobleBuy from IndieBoundBuy from PowellsThe first volume of Melissa Scott’s highly-regarded Roads of Heaven trilogy is an unusual SF novel in that it doesn’t pretend its indistinguishable-from-magic science is anything other than straight-up magic. It’s the sort of thing that makes scientific purists (and guys like me) roll our eyes much of the time. If I have a pet peeve, it’s when a “science” fiction story hits me with paranormal, unscientific concepts, though I suppose that space fantasy has been a subset of space opera for a long time, even long before Star Wars. Scott avoids the claptrap trap, however, by defining her ground rules — precisely how these arcane concepts work within her milieu — early on in her story and then assiduously following them. The end result is an imaginative, compelling story for which readers shouldn’t have trouble suspending disbelief. Throw in a likable trio of LGBT-coded protagonists, solid space opera action, and some social commentary still relevant years after its original publication, and you have a book, and a trilogy, worthy of rediscovery.

We open many centuries in the future. Humanity has spread out to the stars and lost touch with Earth. A new “physics” has been discovered by the mages of the oppressive Hegemony. It allows for faster-than-light travel via the manipulation of “harmonics” — spaceships are literally powered by sound. Silence Leigh, a rarity as a female pilot, navigates her ships not by plotting mathematical coordinates, but through interpreting symbols and “tuning” her vessel (as if it were some kind of celestial receiver) so that it passes successfully into “purgatory” (hyperspace) in an attempt to reach “heaven.” “Heaven” and “hell” are terms that refer to other, non-material planes. The book’s title actually refers to the velocity of her vessel, the Sun-Treader

Why would Scott would bother making up something like this and is it, in fact, a self-indulgent way of cheating the science? Who cares? If SF isn’t a literature that allows for daring flights of imagination, then nothing is. As long as you obey your own rules, you’re gold. Doubts about the story are assuaged as the novel progresses and the power of the magi plays an integral role in the storyline. Ultimately, it’s all kind of neat; an effective way of blending SF and fantasy elements in the kind of space opera setting where hard science might clash too greatly. Still, Scott does tend to write her passages concerning the magecraft with a hard SF writer’s slavish attention to detail. The resulting walls of text make some of the novel’s early chapters slow going.

Silence is on the planet Secasia, trying to avoid being defrauded of her inheritance following the death of her grandfather. Under the Hegemony, women have few rights, and on Secasia, even have to go veiled. But she is saved from her legal problems by off-worlder Denis Balthasar and his crewman, Chase Mago. Balthasar offers Silence an arrangement: Chase cannot get the proper documentation to travel deeply within Hegemon space. But, under the laws of Balthasar’s home world of Delos, Silence can marry both men, enabling Chase to get his papers. In return for this purely-business arrangement, Silence gets the chance to leave her dead-end life and conniving relatives on Secasia and find whatever piloting work she can on Delos, where they’re more progressive about women pilots in general. She agrees, but soon learns to her alarm that Balthasar and Chase haven’t told her everything that they are up to.

Scott’s quasi-mystical concepts do invite comparison to, say, the Jedi Knights and other fantastical Lucas-y stuff-and-nonsense. Of course, Scott’s storytelling has a level of adult sophistication beyond that of Lucas’s escapist juvenilia. The strongest element here: a trio of excellent protagonists, none of whom is too arch, and all of whom, especially Silence, ring true as flawed but sympathetic and convincing people (though of the three, Balthasar could have used much stronger development). Scott’s writing is dense and rich in detail, its only notable flaw her aforementioned tendency toward heavy technical exposition. The tale is generally humorless, too — not that I’d have wanted rote scenes of inane comic relief, but it’s all quite serious going and Scott doesn’t allow us much in the way of lighthearted moments.

Still, Five-Twelfths of Heaven is most rewarding, and an impressive launch to what promises to be a top-flight trilogy. Space opera for grown-ups — that’s my idea of heaven.

Followed by Silence in Solitude.