All reviews and site design © by Thomas M. Wagner. Wink the Astrokitty drawn by Matt Olson. All rights reserved. Book cover artwork is copyrighted by its respective artist and/or publisher.


Search Tips Advanced Search
Search engine by Freefind

Unbury Carol by Josh MalermanUK edition3 stars

Buy from IndieBoundUnbury Carol, the third novel by Josh Malerman, is another exercise in imaginative weird horror that has a smashing and original premise that doesn’t always hang together in the execution. On the whole, I was considerably more entertained by this book than his previous effort, Black Mad Wheel. The story is promoted as a kind of Weird West reimagining of Sleeping Beauty, and it does, overall, make for exciting and suspenseful reading even as you’re aware it’s requiring a bit too much of your suspension of disbelief at key points.

Set in a fictitious community of Old West frontier towns connected by a Trail, it’s the story of Carol Evers, an affluent heiress approaching middle age, very respected in her hometown of Harrow. Married to a ne’er-do-well named Dwight (which should have been a tipoff right there), Carol has a medical condition that causes her to slip into catatonic states that are nearly indistinguishable from actual death, and which can put her under for anywhere from two to four days.

Apart from Dwight, few people know of her condition. Her mother, now dead, knew, of course. As did John Bowie, her Gay Best Friend, who, as the novel opens, has just died of some contagion making its way up and down the towns along the Trail. And there is one other person from Carol’s distant past: James Moxie, her first real love from when she was a spry young thing of eighteen. Moxie, ultimately unable to cope with the emotional pressure of dealing with Carol’s condition, abandoned her for what eventually became the outlaw life, where he would go on to win fame for a duel in which he appeared somehow to kill his opponent without even drawing his gun.

This is where I began having a bit of trouble in the old Willing Suspension of Disbelief department. We are told that Moxie’s leaving her caused Carol such profound abandonment issues that fear of further abandonment is what has kept her from telling anyone else about her condition. And by anyone else, I mean anyone — not the family doctor, not her pastor, or the sheriff, or the funeral director. Carol is described as very popular, and yet she had no women friends in whom she could confide? I’m not buying it, especially as twenty years is plenty of time to get over an ex. I’ve read a good number of nonfiction works about the American West, the settlers and wagon trains and frontier towns, and one thing I’ve learned from them is that the women had a network. They would confide in each other those things you don’t discuss around your menfolk, like which herbs to take to avoid getting pregnant or for terminating an unwanted pregnancy. The thought that Carol, beloved in her community, wouldn’t have had at least a few other sympathetic women to discuss her condition with just didn’t wash for me.

Carol does attempt to confide in Farrah, her housekeeper. But just before she can do so, she slips into a new coma. Dwight, a mustache-twirler out of the old school, decides to seize the opportunity to have Carol, whom he’s secretly resented for years, declared legally dead, because he wants her money. Dwight keeps himself from actually killing Carol while she’s helpless, just to avoid leaving even the hint of physical evidence of foul play. But he hopes that if he movies swiftly and gets Carol in the ground before she wakes up, he’ll be in clover.

But suspicion that something is off troubles Farrah, and troubles her enough to do another thing that doesn’t necessarily ring true from a plot-logic standpoint. Instead of talking to Sheriff Opal, who’s developing suspicions of his own after a visit from the worried funeral director, Farrah fires off a telegram to James Moxie. Moxie has, in recent years, given up his outlaw life and settled down several towns away. And as it happens, he has spent almost all of the intervening years wracked with guilt and remorse for his abandonment of Carol, and the knowledge that his wayward lifestyle was just a feeble cover for emotions he wasn’t man enough to face. Upon getting Farrah’s telegram, Moxie immediately hops on his horse to Harrow to stop Carol’s burial.

At this point the story gets really strange. First, we see Carol in her comatose state, where her mind is active and capable of perceiving what’s going on around her. So she knows full well what Dwight is planning. In her coma, Carol finds herself in a bizarre dark realm she calls Howltown, where her sensation is that of perpetually falling. Desperate to prevent her actual murder, Carol begins trying something she’s never tried before: taking control with her mind and forcing her body to move and wake up from deep within her coma. But Howltown is inhabited by a dark supernatural entity calling itself Rot, manipulating from behind the scenes as it seeks to possess Carol once and for all.

It becomes a race-against-time centered on Moxie’s desperate attempts to rescue Carol before the actual burial. Dwight discovers that Moxie is on his way, panics, and frantically tries to stop the legendary outlaw in his tracks by hiring the most colorful if impractical assassin I’ve ever seen in a story: a psychotic pyromaniac named Smoke who carries a supply of oil inside his two prosthetic legs. Smoke has some fun scenes, don’t get me wrong. But he’s a cartoon villain out of old Dick Tracy comics. I couldn’t help wondering how a killer who doesn’t carry a gun and whose chosen method of murder requires him to walk straight up to his victim, douse them in oil, and strike a match, simply hadn’t been gunned down years ago by literally anyone with a high-powered, long-range rifle. Smoke isn’t exactly shy in his antisocial behavior, eagerly making a public spectacle of himself, and I just couldn’t imagine that no one had sent a heavily armed posse after him, or put a high enough price on his head to interest every bounty hunter within 60 miles. Come on, I’ve played Red Dead Redemption! I know how this works!

Despite all of this, Josh Malerman does give us some solid moments of tension, and Dwight is the kind of villain you love to hate. Moxie’s trick with the duel is eventually explained. Again, I’m not sure I could fully believe his pulling it off — but it does set up a really amusing moment at the climax.

But less satisfying is the way a story that tries to provide Carol agency through her predicament ultimately short-changes both her and us on that front. The premise of a woman in a comatose state having to self-rescue is a terrific one, and frankly, I’m not sure the choice Malerman makes at the end fulfills that premise in a way that lets Carol be the heroine of her own story. The idea of Moxie being motivated in his actions by his acknowledgement of his own wronging of Carol, and a genuine desire to make amends to her, is an admirable way to write a male hero. But in the end, it feels like Unbury Carol is just a bit more his story than hers.