All reviews and site design © by Thomas M. Wagner. Wink the Astrokitty drawn by Matt Olson. All rights reserved. Book cover artwork is copyrighted by its respective artist and/or publisher.


Search Tips Advanced Search
Search engine by Freefind

The Winter of the Witch by Katherine ArdenUK edition4 stars

Buy from IndieBoundWith the conclusion of the Winternight Trilogy, Katherine Arden has given historical fantasy one of its great heroines. The Winter of the Witch is not only a sweeping epic of war and loyalty and betrayal and love and the birth of a nation. It’s also the culmination of Vasilisa Petrovna’s personal journey. Vasya has come such a long way from when we first met her as a misunderstood peasant girl at the beginning of The Bear and the Nightingale, and the road she’s traveled has been fraught with danger and small victories and unbearable anguish the whole way.

Vasya’s a mess in a lot of ways, impulsive and flawed, but also possessed of an unshakable sense of purpose and commitment to those she holds dear, as well as to the people of Russia, despite the torments they’ve made her suffer. Admittedly, that kind of thing can get to be a bit much. If you make your protagonist too noble, you could lose your audience faster than you can say “Christ figure.” But Arden knows how to keep us rooted to Vasya’s humanity through even the story’s biggest emotional set-pieces. This is a character who is charged with nothing less than saving two entire worlds, and bringing them together to coexist in harmony. But we always believe, before anything else, that she’s a young woman faced with a destiny she didn’t choose, and now just has to survive.

In this final chapter, things will get much worse for her and her loved ones and allies before they get better. And there’s always the feeling that even if things resolve happily, the scars of her experiences will stay with Vasya all her days. This is how you create a fictional character as a living, breathing person. Even if nothing else in this book worked, that alone would be a storytelling feat.

Opening at the very moment The Girl in the Tower ends, we see Vasya condemned to die as a witch at the hands of the angry citizens of Moscow, who have been whipped into a frenzied mob by the charismatic priest Konstantin, who’s placed the blame for the burning of the city squarely on her shoulders. The hell of it is, he’s not entirely wrong. But in his encroaching madness, Konstantin is interested only in exploiting the chaos to elevate his station, and he has a bit of sinister help in achieving that goal.

The first forty pages are harrowing, as Vasya undergoes what is known in the screenwriting trade as her “all is lost” moment. This is followed, in turn, by her “dark night of the soul.” She does manage to avoid her fiery execution, when the ordeal unlocks her latent magical abilities. But her only choice is to flee into the realm of Midnight, the supernatural world of the chyerti, which can be accessed by roads only available to those — like Vasya and her niece Marya — who can see the spirit world, and only at midnight, of course.

Without revealing surprises that you all deserve to discover for yourselves, suffice it to say that Vasya’s time in Midnight will involve learning about her family tree, her origins and her true nature. We also get some delightful new supporting characters, like Ded Grib, the little mushroom spirit who provides moments of light comic relief, thankfully without overdoing it. Arden’s writing is as elegant as ever, immersing us in a magical world with a sense of wonder that confirms Arden is the real deal as a fantasy writer.

But one of the book’s flaws is that this section runs much too long, with moments that lapse into exposition, and too much focus on reuniting Vasya with the frost-demon Morozko and consummating their romantic subplot. Because Morozko, you see, has made a bargain to save Vasya’s life — a futile gesture, as it turns out — which has left him imprisoned in Midnight. And this bargain has restored power to an old foe Vasya had hoped she’d seen the last of.

The Bear and the Nightingale was, for the most part, a gentle character-driven fairy tale, while The Girl in the Tower raised the stakes and amped up the action accordingly. The Winter of the Witch tries to be both at once, and Arden eventually just goes for the kitchen sink approach, even throwing in a scene where Vasya helps her brother Sasha and the Grand Prince Dmitrii fight off a horde of the undead attacking the palace. For the most part, the result is rousing entertainment. But the book’s best qualities are those that worked best for The Girl in the Tower: its human touch, emphasizing trust between friends and allies, and bonds of family kinship. There is also the notion of setting aside old rivalries and prejudices to come together for a greater purpose. Vasya’s brother Sasha really comes into his own as a character here, having to overcome the antagonism his Christian faith has caused him to feel towards the pagan spirits of the old world. Sasha is allowed to complete a heroic arc of his own, resulting in an emotionally powerful moment at the story’s denouement.

The Winter of the Witch winds everything up by giving us the spectacle we’ve been craving from the beginning, in a stirring battle scene worthy of Game of Thrones, that offers more than one moment guaranteed to choke you up. The Battle of Kulikovo, as it happens, was a real event. Fought in 1380, it was a turning point in Russian history that many historians point to as paving the way for the formation of the modern Russian state. Learning just how much of what happens in the story happened at the actual battle, and just how many more of the trilogy’s characters are based on real people than I first realized, only raises my estimation of Katherine Arden’s skills. One of the joys of fantasy fiction is that it offers a lens into understanding ourselves and our past, and a saga like the Winternight Trilogy is a lens we should feel privileged to peer into, again and again.